Fat Witch Brownies

September 15, 2020

Fat Witch Brownies

My copy of the Fat Witch Brownies cookbook
The fun British sign in the background always makes me smile.  :o)

Brownies!  Seems that I have had brownies on the brain, lately! :o).  My previous
post, in August, explored the delicious chocolate brownie creation of classic film legend, Katharine Hepburn, here.  Today, I share with you, yet, another brownie recipe. This one, a favorite of Oprah‘s, is called the Fat Witch Brownie , and it hails from the Fat Witch Bakery in New York.
(Check out my post on Oprah’s pick for the best crab cake, here.)

In 2017, I enjoyed Oprah’s favorite crab cake.  Yum!
You can read about that taste test experience, here.

I baked up this Fat Witch batch with the highest of hopes.  Although chocolatey, I still found that my brownie allegiance lies with the Ghirardelli variety.
(I use the Ghirardelli mix, as it results in the taste and texture of the “from scratch” brownie, but can be whipped up in mere minutes .)  If you care to give the Fat Witch brownie a try, the recipe is below. 

The Recipe

Scope out your pantry, and I am guessing that you may already have most of the  ingredients needed for this recipe. I did, except for the unsalted butter.
A 9 x 9 baking pan is needed for baking these.

Fat Witch Brownies
Oprah’s Favorite Brownies


14 Tablespoons (1 +3/4 sticks) unsalted butter

1/2 cup + 2 Tablespoons (Ghirardelli 60% cocoa) bittersweet chocolate chips

1+1/4 cup sugar

4 large eggs

1 teaspoon pure vanilla 

1/2 cup + 2 Tablespoons unbleached flour

Pinch/Dash of salt


Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

Grease 9 x 9 inch baking dish with butter, and dust with flour, tapping out the excess.

Melt butter and chocolate slowly in microwave, or in small saucepan over low heat.
Stir frequently.
Set aside.  Let cool.

Cream sugar, eggs, and vanilla together.
Add cooled chocolate/butter mixture, mixing well, until blended.

Measure flour and salt.  Sift together directly in to the chocolate mixture.
Mix batter gently, just until no trace of dry ingredients remain.
Do not over-mix.

Spread batter evenly in the prepared baking pan.

Bake for 33 minutes, or till a toothpick inserted in center comes out clean, or with only crumbs, not batter, on it.

Remove from oven.  Cool on rack for one hour.

Cut just before serving.

Makes about 12 brownies.

Cooking with Gammy

This antique plug-in toy oven was a precursor of the Easy Bake Oven. :o)

Like many of you, I have been blessed with wonderful (children and) grandchildren.  I love passing on the joy of cooking to my “grands”.  Here are a couple of kid-approved recipes that I have enjoyed using (below), that you can share with your own family members.

Oreo Ice Cream Dessert

This recipe came from one of my fourth grade students many years ago.
It is a keeper.  You will find the recipe on this earlier blog post, here.

Easy S’mores

When some of my “grands” wanted to make s’mores at my house.
Their mother (my smart daughter in-law) suggested this easy recipe!


2 Keebler Fudge Stripes cookies

1 large marshmallow


Place one Keebler Fudge Stripes cookie, chocolate side up.
Place one large marshmallow on top of the cookie.
Place the other cookie, chocolate side down, on top of the marshmallow.
Microwave about 12 seconds in the microwave, or until the marshmallow is melted.

Made Me Smile :o)
Sharing things that put a smile on my face. :o)

Teacher Smiles

 While on my morning walk, I wave to my neighbor, Katya,
as she teaches her students virtually from home.

Nature Walk

What an enjoyable time with a dear friend, as we
(at a social distance)
chatted and strolled through a pretty garden filled with native plantings.

Pretty purple posies in the native garden.


Okay, my family are true Cleveland Indian fans,
but when my friend, Karla, sent me the link to join her Detroit Tigers
(her husband is the Tiger’s chaplain) on Sunday night for Home Plate,
I decided to take a peek.  What an encouraging hour. :o)
Click on the on the arrow above.
For previous Home Plate events, click here.

Other Related Posts, including Brownie Recipes from Previous Posts

 I would love to hear your brownie assessment,
if you give any of these recipes (below) a try!

Katharine Hepburn’s Brownies

Katharine Hepburn’s (Movie Star)BrowniesAugust 2020, here.
A recipe from the star herself.  These brownies are chocolate deliciousness.

Cape Cod Brownies

Lobsters and Clam Chowder and Birthday Cakes, Oh My!, May 2019, here.
This recipe is similar to the Katharine Hepburn recipe (above),
except Hepburn’s uses unsalted butter and 1/2 cup cocoa,
instead of the regular butter and 2 squares of unsweetened chocolate
that are called for in this Cape Cod variety.


Brownie Hearts

Love and Chocolate, February 2018, here.
A heart-shaped cookie cutter help turn these brownies into a tasty Valentine treat.


Ghirardelli Brownies with Aunt Liz’s Glossy Chocolate Frosting

Chicken and Dumplings & Ma and Pa Kettle, September 2014, here.
This post includes my aunt’s recipe for the perfect brownie frosting.


May your days be blessed, and your taste buds happy!
Thank you for reading!


I’m Annette Stuff


Look for my next post on, or around,
October 15, 2020.

Follow My Instagram

Check out my Instagram page at imannettedotnet.

Screen Shot 2019-11-02 at 7.28.14 PM

Get I’m Annette in you Inbox!

Be an I’m Annette follower!  It’s easy!!! It’s fun!!! It’s absolutely free!!!!
Receive my blog via email, FREE, (yes, I said FREE), immediately upon each posting.
Sign up now, on the right-hand side of this page, or click here.

A Special Note to I’m Annette Followers!

If you are receiving this blog via email, and if some of the photos do not come through clearly, please click on imannette.net, or click here to refresh the post.

 Please, Leave a Kind Comment!

Thank you blog readers!  I LOVE hearing your kind comments!
Please post yours positive thoughts in my comment section at the bottom of the blog post.

Check Out Past Blog Posts

To enjoy any, or all, of my past blog posts and photos, click here, or go to imannette.net, selecting the posts that you desire to see in the Recent Posts,
or you can “search” a topic in the Archives sections, in the upper right-hand side.
I have been blogging since 2013, so there are plenty of posts to choose from!

I love it when my grandchildren fill my driveway with their
whimsical chalk drawings.  :o)

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

13 Responses to Fat Witch Brownies

  1. Jennifer Sharpe says:

    Well done! You go girl!!

    Sent from my iPhone


  2. Michelle says:

    OMG! More delicious brownie recipes to add to my collection! You know brownies are my absolute favorite sweet! Love the sidewalk art complements of your wonderful “grands!” Those are some lucky kids to have a grandma like you💕 Another fun blog!


  3. Elizabeth Westphal says:

    Now I am hungry for a brownie, and I am not even a chocoholic! They ALL sound sooo Wonderful…..


  4. Patti Sampson says:

    You’re blog has me craving brownies and chocolate now 🙂 I see brownies in my future. But which ones to try ???? Thanks for all the choices.


  5. marjorie mattson says:

    Made me hungry for brownies looking at your blog. They look yummy.


  6. Renee says:

    These all sound wonderful! I will have to try a few of them out. The s’mores idea is awesome. This one I will use for sure. Thanks!


  7. Pingback: I'm Annette!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s